How to Evaluate Responses to a Project Request for Proposal


Project "RFPs" (Request for Proposals) are most effectively prepared using pre-defined standards that provide content guidelines, along with established viability criteria to facilitate evaluation and promote informed decision making.  That's the simplest way to get things done and to meet all defined objectives.  The key is consistency and built-in flexibility.  Read on for more.

To achieve all the intended benefits, RFP standards must extend beyond the planning and production steps to the types of guidelines and criteria to be used to evaluate the responses received. RFP preparation is only half the battle – to define requirements and solicit related proposals. To reach required goals, you must also be prepared to properly and fairly evaluate the responses received. And you can’t afford to wing it once submissions start rolling in. 

High Quality RFPs = High Quality Responses

In order to receive the highest quality responses, every RFP should be standardized to incorporate the following five (5) content components:

  1. The RFP Should Make Introductions. The RFP should provide basic introductions to the bidder concerning the company (who is requesting the bid) and proposal scope.
  2. The RFP Should Present the Need. The RFP should provide a brief project overview, stating the business case for the project and the need to be filled.
  3. The RFP Should State Requirements. The RFP should state the service and technical requirements and specifications upon which the proposed solution must be based. Every requirements statement should include a "definitions" section to ensure that all parties share a common understanding of all business and technical needs.
  4. The RFP Should Set Terms and Conditions. The RFP should state the expected terms and conditions for solutions acceptance, including delivery requirements, payment terms, and regulatory requirements.
  5. The RFP Should Set Expectations. The RFP should describe the overall RFP bidding process, including response submission requirements, "winning" evaluation and selection criteria, process deadlines, and related technical procedures (response format, submission mechanisms and how to submit questions and feedback).

RFP Content Guidelines and Evaluation Criteria

Once RFP responses are received, each response must be reviewed and evaluated to determine the selected proposal. Using a pre-defined "scoring system", each element of the RFP can then be ranked according to the "degree" to which requirements and priorities are met. To meet these goals, RFP evaluation standards are organized into three (3) actionable components: criteria, degree and priority.

Start with Pre-Defined RFP Evaluation Criteria

  • Physical Requirements: To what degree does this proposal meet stated physical solution requirements (for hardware and/or software)?
  • Service Requirements: To what degree does this proposal meet stated service requirements?
  • Pricing: How does the proposed price compare to the (a) planned budget and to (b) other proposals?
  • Delivery & Installation: To what degree does this proposal meet stated delivery and/or installation requirements?
  • Warranties: To what degree does the proposal meet stated warranty requirements?
  • Terms & Conditions: To what degree does the proposal meet stated contractual terms and conditions?
  • Skills & Abilities: Does the bidder have the necessary skills and abilities to deliver this proposal?
  • References: Does the bidder have a proven track record in this type of project?
  • Intangibles:What other factors can be used to evaluate RFP responses and select the appropriate winner?

Move on to Response Evaluation Scoring

How will RFP's be evaluated? Using a standardized scoring system, "points"can be assigned to each criteria component according to the degree (extent) to which the proposed solution meets stated requirements. This is illustrated below:

  • 5 points: Fully Meets
  • 4 points: Meets, with minor gaps (no compromise required)
  • 3 points: Meets, with moderate gaps (some compromise required)
  • 2 points: Partially meets (significant gaps, compromise required)
  • 1 point: Does not meet

Make Your Evaluation Priority Rankings

The third element of the scoring system is the "priority ranking". In the course of the RFP process, bidders will be asked to respond to multiple requirements. The degree to which each requirement can be met will vary, even within a single proposal. On the other hand, since some requirements will carry more weight than others, wiggle room may exist. Priority rankings will help you to put requirements in perspective, helping you to identify the points at which compromise is possible. For example... You have received several RFP responses and you have identified the solution that best meets your technical requirements. However, this vendor is unable to meet your delivery and installation timeframe. Can you compromise? Priority rankings can help you figure it out, as illustrated below:

  • High Priority: No Compromise Allowed
  • Moderate Priority:Moderate Compromise Allowed
  • Low Priority:Minimal Compromise Allowed

Planning to Prepare the Project Request for Proposal (RFP)

The Request for Proposal (RFP) is an important "project procurement deliverable", used to solicit competitive bids prior to the purchase of project related goods and services.   You don't always need an RFP to make those purchases, but when you do, you need a good one.  Read More


The Project Committee Planner and Template Kit

The Project Committee Planner and Template Kit

The Project Committee Planner and Template Kit provides time-saving steps and customizable templates to organize, operate and evaluate all types of project committees.  Available for instant download.


About Us: We're Right Track Associates, proprietors and publishers of multiple web sites including ITtoolkit.com, Fast Track Manage, HOA Board List and more. We started ITtoolkit.com in 2001 and have continued to grow our web site portfolio, Toolkit products, and related data services.   To learn more, start with our home page.

Learn more about the Service Strategy Toolkit from ITtoolkit.com

IT'S TIME FOR THE I.T. SERVICE STRATEGY TOOLKIT

From ITtoolkit.com!

Are you ready to lead your I.T. department to become more valued, relevant and responsive? If so, then you need the IT Service Strategy Toolkit from ITtoolkit.com! The Toolkit teaches you how to "add value" to IT projects and services -- using our time-saving "service strategy process". It's ready for instant download, filled with 400+ pages of steps, guidelines, practices and templates. Find Out More

Featured Content

While you're here, don't forget to check out our collection of free templates, whitepapers and management infographics.

ITtoolkit.com Whitepapers and Templates

ITtoolkit.com Infographics

Popular Article Categories

You can find our most popular blog articles at the links below, organized by subject matter.

FEATURED MANAGEMENT TOPIC:

Project Fast Tracking

What is it?

Strategic "project fast tracking" is a streamlined project management process, specifically used to overcome the most common types of project obstacles, including insufficient time, resource shortages, budgetary deficiencies and stakeholder conflicts.

Articles:

Part 1: What is Strategic Fast Tracking?

Part 2: Evaluating Projects for Fast-Track-Ability

Part 3: Pinpointing Project Priorities

Infographics:

Get an illustrated view of the fast tracking process in the "Step-by-Step to a Fast Tracked Project" infographic.

Tools and Templates:

Learn more about the Fast Track Project Toolkit

The Fast Track Project Toolkit provides the entire "fast tracking" methodology in one complete package, filled with how-to concepts, practices and templates. Available for instant download.


Articles, Tips & Offers Right to Your Inbox

Sign up for the ITtoolkit.com newsletter and be the first to know about our latest blog articles, templates, white papers, infographics, and special offers.

We won't overload your inbox and we don't share or sell subscriber information. Just enter your email address below.