Using Informed Decision Making to Defeat Analysis Paralysis

  • from ITtoolkit.com

Woman in front of six doors unable to decide which door to use, illustrating analysis paralysis.

There is no doubt that it takes a lot of "analysis and decision making" to deliver successful IT services, operations and projects.  But this begs an important question -- when every major project, plan, decision, and solution depends upon the meaningful analysis of goals, requirements, alternatives and consequences, can there ever be too much analysis?  The answer is yes.  At some point, action must be taken or the "opportunity of the moment" may be lost.  It's a fine line, but you can read on to learn when that line has to be crossed.

What is Analysis Paralysis?

In the IT management context, analysis paralysis manifests itself through exceedingly long phases of project planning, requirements gathering, program design and modeling, with little or no extra value created by those steps.  Per Wikipedia:

"In order to maintain forward momentum, and deliver required projects and services, "analysis" must serve a specific purpose, whether to aide a decision or produce a deliverable. Analysis related activities must be executed to move a project or process forward.  Once in "paralysis mode", activities cease to contribute to the bottom line, becoming "empty and excessive".

What Causes Analysis Paralysis?

Analysis paralysis is usually caused by a well-intentioned, but misplaced focus on "work instead of results", characterized by one or more of the following:

  • The uncontrolled collection of excessive amounts of data and information.
  • Ongoing unproductive activities (meetings) creating an appearance of forward movement (activity is confused with "accomplishment").
  • Excessive attention to process deliverables (reports and studies).
  • Decision avoidance ... i.e. frequent requests for changes and/or additional information just at the point at which decisions could otherwise be made.
  • Fear of failure or error - "If I don't take action, I can't make a mistake".
  • Fear of obsolescence ... "What if something better comes along, what if some new information is available?"

Turn to an Analysis Framework

Analysis has a simple goal.... to reach the best conclusion possible, based on reasonable, verified information and informed consensus. How can this be achieved without excess? The first step towards avoiding, or at least minimizing, analysis paralysis is to define appropriate process limits and expectations. Analysis is not a deliverable in and of itself, it is a process used to create a deliverable, and as such, it must be defined by specific goals, tasks, deadlines and results. This can be achieved through the creation of an analysis framework.


Work Smarter

Even under the best of circumstances, management is a challenge. When you learn to fast track, you’ll learn to work smarter, not harder. And that’s the value of every lesson, resource and template available at Fast Track Manage Learning. We teach you how to fast track your way to successful projects, committees and more. Learn More


Defeating Analysis Paralysis: Your To-Do List

The analysis framework is used to establish (5) defining parameters for the ensuing process, setting the stage for the work to be done. Using the framework, you can avoid the type of open-ended, undefined process inevitably leading to "analysis paralysis".

Step 1: Set process goals and objectives.

What is the driving force behind this analysis? Why is this analysis necessary and how will it add value to the project or issue at hand? What is the urgency? What are the risks if this analysis is not undertaken?

Step 2: Set process limits with a defined scope.

How will this analysis be used to influence the decision, plan or project at hand? Note:If the pending analysis cannot be tied to a specific need or result, it is time to rethink the whole thing. What are the expected results (deliverable) of this analysis?Note: Depending on the project, problem or issue at hand, analysis deliverables can include decisions, recommendations, plans and problem "plans of attack". What is the minimal amount of information required to reach the desired result? Can this analysis occur in "phases", to allow other work to begin even if all "analysis" is not yet complete?   (Also See: Easy Ways to Define Project Scope).

Step 3: Set a deadline.

Every analytical process should proceed along a defined timeline, with an established (and communicated) deadline.Without a firm deadline, analysis can become a never-ending cycle of "wait, here's some new information", or "let's have another meeting". Analysis should never be open-ended, it should always be tied to a specific goal and a specific deadline. Any and all changes to this deadline should be considered carefully, and allowed only when absolutely necessary.

Step 4: Define tasks, with assigned roles and responsibilities.

How will this analysis process be executed? Who will be involved? What tasks are required for data collection, organization, analysis and deliverables production?

Step 5: Establish success criteria.

Success criteria will help you to set expectations and avoid "analysis" scope creep. Defined success criteria will also help you to respond when and if problems arise, and you are in need a "plan B".  (Also See:  Defining Realistic Criteria for Project Success)

Source: Unless noted otherwise, all content is created by and for ITtoolkit.com


About Us

Right Track Logo

ITtoolkit.com staff writers have experience working for some of the largest corporations, in various positions including marketing, systems engineering, help desk support, web and application development, and IT management.

ITtoolkit.com is part of Right Track Associates, proprietors and publishers of multiple web sites including ITtoolkit.com, Fast Track Manage, HOA Board List and more. We started ITtoolkit.com in 2001 and have continued to grow our web site portfolio, Toolkit products, and related data services. To learn more, visit us at Right Track Associates.

Stay Informed

Useful information without inbox overload.

we do not sell our list

subscribe now
I.T. Service Planning The Fast Track Project Toolkit Start For Free

The IT Service Strategy Toolkit teaches you how to fast track IT service planning using the time-saving “service strategy process”. The goals are simple... to manage IT departments, services and projects in a common-sense manner, to align business and technology, and realize maximum value, acceptance, and utilization - all at the lowest overhead costs. It’s all about adding value, in less time and with greater success. Get lifetime access to a growing IT service curriculum of lessons, videos, reference materials, templates and more. Start for free.

Committee Management The Project Committee Toolkit Start For Free

The Project Committee Toolkit teaches you how to manage successful committees using the "committee concept" process. Committees are one of the most effective ways to organize, deliberate and make decisions. But too often, committee success is hampered by conflict and bureaucracy. When you follow the committee concept process, you’ll learn to avoid these pitfalls and ensure that your committees are properly formed, managed and staffed. Get lifetime access to a growing committee management curriculum of lessons, videos, reference materials, templates and more. Start for free.

Project Management The Fast Track Project Toolkit Start For Free

The Fast Track Project Toolkit teaches you how to deliver on-time, on-plan projects using "strategic project fast tracking". The fast track approach is a time-saving methodology, designed specifically for "real world" project circumstances - when you are being asked to do more than time and resources may allow. Fast tracking is the way to work around these obstacles and deliver prioritized results. Get lifetime access to a growing project planning curriculum of lessons, videos, reference materials, templates and more. Start for free.