Easy Steps for Evaluating Project Team Performance

Project teams have a limited shelf life. They exist for the duration of a given project, and once the project is complete, the team is disbanded, with its members returning to their operational assignments, or moving on to the next project.  But, while the organizational entity is gone, the performance legacy lives on.  And, this legacy has an important purpose - to deliver important "project lessons learned".  Read on for more.

When it comes to project team performance, there are only two possibilities -- the "team" will either help or hinder project execution and results.  Clearly, you always want to be on the positive side of that equation.  But it's not a given - that's why team evaluation is so important.   Even under the best conditions, there's always something to learn and multiple ways to improve.  In fact, team performance is multi-layered, considering all of the varied skills it takes to complete a given project, as well as the unique "persona" of each and every project team.  Also Read:  Best Ways to Offer Constructive Criticism

Start with Team Evaluation Basics

Considering these diverse variables, fully comprehensive performance evaluations must consider the multiple "levels" of performance, organized into four (4) categories:

Top-Down Analysis:

  • Objectives: The top-down analysis examines team performance from a management perspective, evaluating the team as a whole and on a individual member basis.
  • Participants: Project managers and team leaders.
  • Primary Questions: Did the team perform as expected and required, both as a cooperative unit and on an individual basis? Were skills properly exercised and combined? Did everyone participate actively and positively? Were there any internal conflicts that damaged team performance?

Bottom-Up Analysis:

  • Objectives: The bottom-up analysis examines management performance from a team "participant" perspective. The goal is to measure team satisfaction with management.
  • Participants: Project team members.
  • Primary Questions: Did the project management hierarchy create an environment for success considering planning strategies, work assignments, information, motivation, empowerment and support?

Peer to Peer Analysis:

  • Objectives: The peer to peer analysis provides the opportunity for a ground level team assessment, allowing the individual team members to evaluate each other.
  • Participants: Project team members.
  • Primary Questions: Did each team member carry out his/her responsibilities as required? Did each team member support the "unit", by sharing information and following procedures?Did each team member show sufficient courtesy and respect to fellow team members? Did team members work to resolve internal conflicts?

Customer Analysis:

  • Objectives: The customer analysis provides the opportunity for "customer" evaluation of team performance.
  • Participants: Project customers.
  • Primary Questions: Was the project team responsive to customer needs? Were customers sufficiently included in team deliberations and activities? Did the team actively seek customer input and feedback as needed?
"A picture speaks louder than 1,000 words".  Get an illustrated view of the project review and lessons learned process in our informative infographic Lessons Learned: The Road to Continuous Improvement.

Steps for Performance Evaluation Execution

Timely and effective "team evaluations" can (and should be) performed at any time in the project lifecycle, whenever appropriate and worthwhile. The goal is to quickly collect the data to be used for performance evaluation and then evaluate that data considering established goals and benchmarks.  This is all reflected in the quick to-do list below:

  • Identify your performance evaluation objectives (i.e. to improve future project performance, improve customer relationships, or to identify and resolve performance problems mid-project).
  • Select your performance evaluation mechanisms (i.e. surveys, interviews or informal review meetings).
  • Identify your evaluation scope (top-down, bottom-up, peer to peer and/or customer).
  • Select your participants (entire team or a representative sample).
  • Analyze evaluation results (strengths, weaknesses and related areas for improvement).
  • Apply evaluation results as needed to suit the objectives identified in "step 1".

Once team performance evaluation results are known, the results must be applied in order to ensure that quality performance is repeated and problem performance is avoided. The resulting actions will depend largely upon the lessons learned conclusions reached --- i.e. why did the project team perform well or why did the project team fail to perform?  At the end of the day, the value of the team performance evaluation lies in the ability to use resulting conclusions to sustain strengths and overcome weaknesses.

The Project Committee Planner and Template Kit

The Project Committee Planner and Template Kit

The Project Committee Planner and Template Kit provides time-saving steps and customizable templates to organize, operate and evaluate all types of project committees.  Available for instant download.

About Us: We're Right Track Associates, proprietors and publishers of multiple web sites including ITtoolkit.com, Fast Track Manage, HOA Board List and more. We started ITtoolkit.com in 2001 and have continued to grow our web site portfolio, Toolkit products, and related data services.   To learn more, start with our home page.

Learn more about the Service Strategy Toolkit from ITtoolkit.com


From ITtoolkit.com!

Are you ready to lead your I.T. department to become more valued, relevant and responsive? If so, then you need the IT Service Strategy Toolkit from ITtoolkit.com! The Toolkit teaches you how to "add value" to IT projects and services -- using our time-saving "service strategy process". It's ready for instant download, filled with 400+ pages of steps, guidelines, practices and templates. Find Out More

Featured Content

While you're here, don't forget to check out our collection of free templates, whitepapers and management infographics.

ITtoolkit.com Whitepapers and Templates

ITtoolkit.com Infographics

Popular Article Categories

You can find our most popular blog articles at the links below, organized by subject matter.


Project Fast Tracking

What is it?

Strategic "project fast tracking" is a streamlined project management process, specifically used to overcome the most common types of project obstacles, including insufficient time, resource shortages, budgetary deficiencies and stakeholder conflicts.


Part 1: What is Strategic Fast Tracking?

Part 2: Evaluating Projects for Fast-Track-Ability

Part 3: Pinpointing Project Priorities


Get an illustrated view of the fast tracking process in the "Step-by-Step to a Fast Tracked Project" infographic.

Tools and Templates:

Learn more about the Fast Track Project Toolkit

The Fast Track Project Toolkit provides the entire "fast tracking" methodology in one complete package, filled with how-to concepts, practices and templates. Available for instant download.

Articles, Tips & Offers Right to Your Inbox

Sign up for the ITtoolkit.com newsletter and be the first to know about our latest blog articles, templates, white papers, infographics, and special offers.

We won't overload your inbox and we don't share or sell subscriber information. Just enter your email address below.